Thinking about replacing that old bathtub with a sleek, modern walk-in shower? It's a great way to update your bathroom, but there are a few things worth knowing before the demolition begins.

Let's face it. For plenty of homeowners in Saline, Michigan, the bathtub has become little more than an oversized shower floor with a 15-inch obstacle to climb over every morning. If you're not regularly soaking in the tub, why keep it?

Replacing a bathtub with a walk-in shower can make your bathroom feel bigger, improve accessibility, simplify cleaning, and bring an outdated space into the 21st century.

But here's the catch: A tub-to-shower conversion isn't always as simple as pulling out the bathtub and sliding a shower into its place.

Whether you live in one of Saline's charming older homes near downtown, an established ranch-style home, or a newer subdivision off Ann Arbor-Saline Road, your home's plumbing, framing, and bathroom configuration can significantly affect the project.

Fortunately, today's homeowners have more options than ever, including beautiful, low-maintenance shower systems that can eliminate many of the headaches associated with traditional tile.

Before you start picking out showerheads and fancy glass doors, let's look at what you should know.

1. Your Bathtub Drain May Not Be Where Your Shower Needs It

One of the first things to consider is plumbing.

Most bathtubs have a drain near one end. Many shower bases, however, have their drains closer to the center. That difference can create extra work.

If your bathroom is above an unfinished basement, relocating a drain may be relatively straightforward. But if it's on a concrete slab or above a finished ceiling, things can become more complicated.

You may also discover that the existing drain piping needs to be modified to accommodate the new shower system.

Other plumbing considerations include:

  • Drain placement: Can you select a shower base that works with your existing drain location?
  • Drain size: Does the existing piping meet the requirements for the new shower?
  • Shower controls: Will the faucet and mixing valve remain in their current location?
  • Showerhead placement: Are you adding a handheld sprayer, rainfall showerhead, or other fixtures?
  • Older plumbing: Will existing supply lines or drain connections need to be repaired or replaced?

Be aware that plumbing-code requirements for bathtubs and showers can differ. Existing bathtubs frequently have 1½-inch drains, while a new shower installation may require a larger drain depending on the applicable code, fixture specifications, and plumbing configuration. Determining whether existing piping can be reused is an important part of estimating the project.

And there's one potentially helpful solution: Some manufacturers offer shower bases with drain locations designed specifically for bathtub replacements. Selecting one of these systems can sometimes reduce the need for extensive plumbing modifications.

Our advice: Check the existing drain size and location before selecting your shower. Whenever possible, choose a system that works with your existing plumbing configuration while meeting applicable code requirements.

2. Older Saline Homes May Have a Few Surprises Behind the Walls

Saline has a wonderful mix of historic homes, mid-century houses, and newer residential developments. That variety is part of the city's charm, but it also means bathroom renovations can present very different challenges.

In some of the older homes closer to downtown Saline, previous renovations may have left behind outdated plumbing, uneven floors, or unusual framing arrangements.

Even a newer house isn't necessarily immune to problems.

Once the bathtub comes out, you might discover:

  • Rotted or water-damaged subflooring
  • Mold or moisture damage behind the tub surround
  • Deteriorated wall studs or framing
  • Plumbing leaks that have gone unnoticed for years
  • Uneven floors or walls that complicate installation

Many of these problems aren't visible until demolition is underway.

And although nobody enjoys an unexpected repair, it's far better to discover and correct water damage now than to install a beautiful new shower over a deteriorating structure.

Another complication we've encountered, particularly in older homes, is walls that are no longer perfectly straight, square, or plumb. Years of settling can leave framing out of alignment, sometimes requiring significant correction before installing a shower.

This matters whether you're installing tile or a manufactured shower system. Large wall panels need a properly prepared substrate, just as tile does. Trying to make either system fit badly uneven walls without addressing the underlying problem can compromise the finished appearance and installation.

Fortunately, some high-quality shower systems offer panels that can be trimmed to fit and specialized trim pieces to accommodate minor wall irregularities.

Our advice: Include a reasonable contingency allowance in your budget. If everything behind the old bathtub looks terrific, wonderful! If not, you'll be better prepared to address the problem properly.

3. The Most Important Part of Your Shower Is the Part You Can't See

Let's talk waterproofing.

It's tempting to spend most of your planning time deciding between subway tile, large-format porcelain, and that gorgeous glass enclosure you saw online.

But the real star of a successful shower installation is hidden behind the finished surfaces.

Unlike a bathtub, which holds water within a single manufactured fixture, a custom tiled shower depends on a properly designed waterproofing system.

That means paying close attention to the shower base, wall membranes, corners, seams, plumbing penetrations, and transitions between materials.

Here's something many homeowners don't realize: Tile and grout alone do not make a shower waterproof.

Water can penetrate grout joints and other vulnerable areas. The waterproofing system behind the tile is what protects the underlying structure.

This is one reason manufactured shower pan-and-panel systems have become an attractive alternative.

Instead of hundreds of grout lines, these systems generally use large, continuous wall panels and a one-piece shower base. That means far fewer joints to clean, maintain, and monitor.

Fewer joints don't automatically mean a leak-proof shower, of course. The connections between panels, the shower base, and plumbing fixtures still need to be properly sealed according to the manufacturer's instructions.

But reducing the number of seams can eliminate many of the maintenance concerns homeowners associate with tiled showers.

Our advice: Don't evaluate a shower solely by its finished appearance. Ask how water will be contained, how joints will be sealed, and what maintenance will be required over time.

4. Choosing the Right Shower: Tile or a Modern Pan-and-Panel System?

Not every Saline homeowner needs a high-end custom tiled shower.

In fact, one of the biggest improvements in bathroom remodeling has been the development of sophisticated, solid-surface shower systems that deliver a premium appearance without all the grout lines.

There are several approaches worth considering.

Pan-and-panel shower systems: Less grout, less maintenance, plenty of style

A pan-and-panel system typically consists of a manufactured shower base paired with large wall panels designed to create a coordinated shower enclosure.

Unlike traditional tile, the wall panels cover large areas without requiring individual tiles and hundreds of grout joints.

The benefits can be significant:

  • Fewer potential leak points: Large panels eliminate most of the grout joints that require maintenance in tiled showers.
  • Easier cleaning: Smooth, nonporous wall surfaces generally resist dirt and soap buildup and don't require scrubbing grout lines.
  • Simpler maintenance: There is no field of grout joints to periodically repair or reseal.
  • More predictable installation: The system uses manufactured components rather than requiring an individually constructed tile surface.
  • Design flexibility: Premium systems offer multiple colors, textures, shower base configurations, and accessories.

That doesn't mean all pan-and-panel systems are equal. Materials, thickness, construction, appearance, warranty coverage, and installation requirements can vary considerably.

For homeowners looking for a quality solution rather than a basic plastic shower enclosure, choosing the right manufacturer makes a substantial difference.

A premium option: The Onyx Collection

One manufacturer we particularly like is The Onyx Collection, an American manufacturer of made-to-order shower bases, wall panels, and bathroom accessories.

Unlike many standard, off-the-shelf shower kits, Onyx products can be ordered to suit specific dimensions, colors, and configurations.

That makes them especially interesting for tub-to-shower conversions, where the existing bathroom doesn't always conform to today's standard shower dimensions.

Some of the features that make Onyx worth considering include:

  • Customizable shower bases: Standard and custom sizes, including configurations suited to bathtub replacement projects.
  • Large solid-surface wall panels: Generally, one panel per wall, significantly reducing the number of joints compared with traditional tile.
  • Multiple finishes: Smooth gloss, subway-tile appearance, stone-tile appearance, and other decorative finishes that provide different looks without conventional grout joints.
  • Coordinated accessories: Matching shower seats, corner caddies, shelving, and trim.
  • Low-threshold options: Shower bases designed to provide easier entry.
  • Manufacturer guarantee: The Onyx Collection promotes its products with a "Yes, Guaranteed Forever" guarantee, subject to its published warranty terms.

Onyx also offers wall panels that can be trimmed during installation and corner trim designed to accommodate certain irregularities in existing walls. That can be particularly useful when remodeling some of Saline's older houses.

Perhaps the most appealing feature, though, is the combination of appearance and practicality. You can achieve a sophisticated shower without committing to the cleaning and maintenance associated with traditional tile grout.

One important distinction: Onyx systems still have seams where panels meet and where walls connect to the shower base. Those joints must be sealed with the manufacturer's specified silicone products, and the underlying walls must be properly prepared. It's a lower-maintenance approach, not an excuse to skip proper installation.

For homeowners interested in exploring these options, visit The Onyx Collection at https://onyxcollection.com/ to see available finishes, shower bases, and accessories.

Manufactured shower pan with tiled walls

Another popular approach combines a manufactured shower base with traditionally tiled walls. This provides some of the advantages of a one-piece shower floor while retaining the appearance and design flexibility of ceramic or porcelain tile. It's an appealing compromise for homeowners who love tile but want to avoid the complexity of building a custom tiled shower floor.

Fully tiled walk-in showers

If you're looking for a completely customized appearance, with decorative tile, built-in niches, benches, and unusual dimensions, a fully tiled shower may be the right choice.

Properly installed tile showers can be beautiful and durable.

However, they typically require more installation labor, extensive waterproofing, and ongoing grout maintenance.

Curbless showers

For homeowners interested in accessibility or aging in place, a curbless shower eliminates the raised threshold. Both custom tile and certain manufactured systems can accommodate low-entry or accessible designs. However, achieving a completely curbless entry may require modifications to the floor structure and drainage arrangement.

Our advice: Don't assume a custom tiled shower is automatically the premium choice. A high-quality pan-and-panel system like The Onyx Collection may offer a better combination of appearance, durability, maintenance, and value for many homeowners.

5. Glass Doors Look Great, but They're Not Always the Best Answer

Who doesn't love the look of a frameless glass shower enclosure? It creates an open, contemporary feel and can make a smaller bathroom appear more spacious. But glass comes with additional considerations. Sliding doors can work well in a standard bathtub-sized opening, while hinged doors require adequate clearance.

Fixed glass panels can be particularly attractive, but they may not contain water as effectively as a fully enclosed shower, especially in a relatively short five-foot opening.

And here's a radical thought: There's absolutely nothing wrong with a shower curtain!

A quality curtain and rod can be practical, attractive, easy to maintain, and considerably less expensive than custom glass. Many manufactured shower systems, including Onyx, can be paired with different types of enclosures depending on the shower configuration.

Before selecting an enclosure, consider the size of the shower, the location of the showerhead, the direction of the spray, and the available bathroom space.

Our advice: Decide how the shower will be enclosed before installation begins. Some glass systems require additional wall reinforcement or specific mounting locations.

6. Planning to Stay in Your Saline Home? Think About Accessibility

Many homeowners convert a bathtub into a shower because they're tired of stepping over the tub wall. And as we get older, that seemingly minor inconvenience can become a genuine safety concern.

For homeowners planning to remain in their Saline homes for many years, a shower conversion is an opportunity to incorporate features that improve comfort and accessibility.

Consider adding:

  • A low-threshold or curbless entry
  • Slip-resistant shower flooring
  • A handheld showerhead
  • Grab bars with proper structural support
  • A built-in or folding shower seat
  • Easy-to-reach shower controls

Manufactured systems can be especially attractive for accessibility improvements because some offer coordinated seats, low-profile bases, and accessories designed to work together.

For example, The Onyx Collection offers shower seating options, matching accessories, and different shower base configurations that can support a more accessible bathroom design.

Even if you don't need grab bars today, installing reinforcement inside the walls during construction is relatively inexpensive.

Adding that reinforcement later? Not so much.

Our advice: Plan for tomorrow's needs while you're working on today's bathroom. Small improvements during construction can make a big difference down the road.

7. Should You Remove the Only Bathtub in Your House?

This is an especially important question in a community like Saline, where many homes appeal to families with children. While walk-in showers are increasingly popular, bathtubs still serve an important purpose for households with young kids.

If your house has two or three bathrooms and another bathtub remains, converting one tub into a shower may be an easy decision. But if you're thinking about eliminating the only bathtub, consider the potential effect on resale appeal.

A beautiful walk-in shower may attract buyers, particularly those interested in accessibility and low-maintenance living. On the other hand, some families may prefer a home with at least one bathtub. There's no universal right answer.

Our advice: If you're planning to stay in your home for the foreseeable future, prioritize what works best for you. If you expect to sell soon, give some thought to the preferences of future buyers.

8. What About Permits and Licensed Contractors in Saline?

A tub-to-shower conversion can involve several trades, including demolition, carpentry, plumbing, waterproofing, tile or panel installation, and finish work.

In Michigan, alterations to plumbing systems may require a plumbing permit and work by an appropriately licensed plumbing professional.

For homes within the City of Saline, the city administers building and trade permits, including plumbing permits. Requirements for a particular conversion depend on the work being performed.

Homes with a Saline mailing address but located outside city limits may fall under another permitting authority.

Replacing a shower surround is quite different from moving a drain, relocating water supply lines, or modifying electrical wiring.

Our advice: Before construction begins, establish which permits and specialty trades your project requires. An experienced home improvement contractor can help identify the work involved and coordinate the project appropriately.

9. How Long Does a Tub-to-Shower Conversion Take?

Some shower replacement companies make it sound as though every bathtub can be transformed into a beautiful shower overnight. Occasionally, a relatively simple replacement really can move quickly.

But not every bathroom is that cooperative.

A typical project may involve:

  1. Removing the existing bathtub, wall surround, and necessary finishes
  2. Inspecting the framing, subfloor, and plumbing
  3. Completing necessary structural repairs, wall straightening, and plumbing alterations
  4. Installing the shower base and preparing the walls
  5. Installing the shower panels or tile and completing the required waterproofing and sealing
  6. Completing plumbing trim, enclosure installation, and finish work

One advantage of a pan-and-panel system is that large manufactured wall panels can often be installed more quickly than individually setting, grouting, and finishing tile.

However, the existing space still needs to be properly prepared, and adhesive and sealant curing requirements must be followed.

A straightforward conversion using a manufactured shower system might take several working days. A fully tiled shower, plumbing relocation, or substantial water damage can add considerable time. Inspections, material availability, and required curing times also need to be considered.

And with made-to-order products such as Onyx, homeowners should account for manufacturing and delivery time before scheduling demolition.

Our advice: Ask for a realistic schedule and understand how long your shower will be out of service. This is especially important if you're remodeling the only full bathroom in the house.

10. The Secret to a Successful Conversion? Plan First, Demolish Second.

Converting a bathtub into a walk-in shower can be one of the most practical improvements you make to your home. You can create a more attractive bathroom, make everyday routines easier, improve accessibility, and eliminate a fixture you rarely use. But successful conversions begin with understanding the existing space.

Can the drain stay where it is? Are the walls and subfloor sound? Which shower system makes the most sense? Do you really need custom glass? And what happens if you find damage during demolition? Just as importantly, think about how you want to maintain your bathroom.

If you love the appearance of custom tile and don't mind caring for grout, a tiled shower can be a wonderful investment.

If you'd prefer a beautiful, durable shower with fewer seams and less routine maintenance, a quality pan-and-panel system deserves serious consideration.

These aren't particularly glamorous questions, but answering them early can make the difference between a smooth renovation and a costly surprise.

For Saline homeowners, the key is finding the right balance between appearance, function, budget, and the realities of your home's construction.

Ready to Say Goodbye to That Old Bathtub?

At Ace Handyman Services Ann Arbor, we help homeowners in Saline and surrounding Washtenaw County communities tackle bathroom improvement projects with practical solutions and quality craftsmanship.

Our experienced Craftsmen offer a broad range of skills, including demolition, carpentry, wall and floor repairs, shower system installation, tile work, and finishing details. We can also help identify when a project requires additional licensed specialty trades.

Whether you're considering a custom tiled shower or a premium pan-and-panel system like The Onyx Collection, we'll help you understand the options, evaluate potential complications, and develop a plan that makes sense for your home.

Because the best bathroom renovation isn't necessarily the fanciest one. It's the one that works beautifully, fits your budget, and doesn't leave you wondering what surprises are hiding behind the walls.

Contact Ace Handyman Services Ann Arbor to discuss your tub-to-shower conversion in Saline, Michigan.

GET STARTED
Posted on Categories